Becker's Clinical Quality & Infection Control

September 2017 Issue of Becker's Clinical

Issue link: https://beckershealthcare.uberflip.com/i/879374

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 8 of 47

9 INFECTION CONTROL & PATIENT SAFETY 3 Things Hospitals Can Do Now to Address Overlapping Surgeries By Heather Punke T he prevalence of concurrent and overlapping surgeries came to light for the first time for many Americans in 2015, when e Boston Globe's famed Spotlight Team reported on the practices at Boston-based Massachusetts General Hospital. Since then, the debate over the controversial practice has affected policies at hospitals across the country. In a recent viewpoint article in JAMA, Mi- chelle Mello, PhD, a health law scholar with Stanford Law School, and Edward Living- ston, MD, a physician who is also deputy editor of JAMA, discussed the overlapping surgery debate and what hospitals should do to regulate the practice. First, they drew a line in the sand between overlapping and concurrent surgeries. ey called overlapping surgeries a "com- mon" practice in which the start time of one surgery overlaps with the end of another for the same primary surgeon. Meanwhile, concurrent surgeries occur when "critical parts of operations for which the primary surgeon is responsible occur during the same time," the authors wrote, adding "there is a general agreement that concurrent surgery is ethically unacceptable and is prohibited for teaching hospitals" by Medicare. Studies have shown that overlapping surger- ies don't differ much from non-overlapping surgeries. Overlapping surgeries usually took longer on average, but that extended length was not associated with any negative effect on patient outcomes. "Overall, the modest evidence base does not suggest that overlapping surgery is unsafe, but rather that the practice is not trusted, at least by individuals considering the practice in the abstract without the benefit of an established patient-surgeon relationship," the authors wrote. Hospitals should do the following to build trust among patients whose surgeries may overlap with another case. 1. Full disclosure. Hospitals need to fully inform patients of overlapping surgery scheduling practices well before the surgery is scheduled. is disclosure should include the likelihood that the operation will involve an overlap, a description of who will perform which parts of the operation and what their qualifications are," as well as what the patient can do if they object to the overlap, accord- ing to the authors. 2. Clear definitions. During an overlapping surgery, the main surgeon completes the crit- ical portions of the surgery but may be ab- sent during the start or end of the procedure. While the American College of Surgeons has a broad definition of what critical portions are — "those stages when essential technical expertise and surgical judgment are neces- sary to achieve an optimal patient outcome" — Drs. Mello and Livingston say hospitals need to get more specific. "[T]he definition of the critical portion should be established by a multidisciplinary committee within the hospital," instead of leaving it up to surgeons to define what "critical" means. 3. Oversight. Hospitals need to ensure surgeons really are present for critical parts of procedures, the authors wrote. is can be achieved by having surgeons clock in and out of the OR so there is a record of when they are there — this is now the law in Massachu- setts, according to the authors. Following these three steps "can do much to ensure that abuses of overlapping scheduling do not further undermine public trust in the practice of surgery," they concluded. n Do Cellphones in the OR Jeopardize Patient Safety? 5 Thoughts By Mackenzie Bean M anuel Alvarez, MD, adjunct professor of obstet- rics and gynecology at New York University School of Medicine in New York City, weighed the pros and cons of physician cellphone use in the op- erating room in an editorial for Fox News Health. Here are five thoughts from Dr. Alvarez, who also serves as a senior managing editor of health news for the on- line publication. 1. Cellphones allow physicians in the OR to access help- ful medical apps, look up critical information or rapidly call for help, if need be. However, hospitals cannot properly monitor physicians to ensure they are using their phones solely for work purposes, according to Dr. Alvarez. 2. Physicians who use their cellphones in the OR to sim- ply "kill time" jeopardize patient safety, wrote Dr. Alvarez. 3. He also noted cellphones, which often carry bacteria, increase a patient's infection risk when used in the OR. 4. Physicians may also use cellphones to insecurely access and share private patient information. A 2016 report from Skycure found 14 percent of physicians store patient data on their phones without a password, and more than 60 percent of physicians transfer patient information via text message. 5. "While experts cannot give an exact number for med- ical errors related to cellphones, devices clearly risk pa- tient safety," Dr. Alvarez concluded. "Doctors should do everything within their power to stay alert and decrease infections during surgery. Staying off their devices will ensure this level of excellence. Hospitals and doctors should work together to put a strategy in place and en- force it. After all, patient safety is at stake." n

Articles in this issue

view archives of Becker's Clinical Quality & Infection Control - September 2017 Issue of Becker's Clinical