Becker's Hospital Review

November 2019 Becker's Hospital Review

Issue link: https://beckershealthcare.uberflip.com/i/1179082

Contents of this Issue

Navigation

Page 31 of 79

32 POPULATION HEALTH 32 CEO/STRATEGY Female board directors help curb overconfidence of male CEOs, study finds By Morgan Haefner W hen female board members are present, male CEOs tend to ex- hibit less overconfidence, accord- ing to a study published in the Journal of Em- pirical Finance. For the study, European researchers ex- amined data from 1,629 U.S. firms on their CEOs and boards, according to an accom- panying Harvard Business Review article on the study. During the study period, 1998 to 2013, researchers found men were dispro- portionately represented among CEOs and board members. e study authors looked at whether CEOs were less likely to act overcon- fident when female board leaders were pres- ent and how their presence may have affected corporate decisions and performance. e researchers found male CEOs with wom- en on their company boards are less likely to hold options when exercising them would lead to profits, in comparison to male CEOs at companies without female directors, ac- cording to HBR. e researchers used hold- ing or exercising options to study overconfi- dence, as the choice is a personal one made by the CEO and "likely to reveal a CEO's individual beliefs and confidence about the company," they said. Interestingly, female directors had a larg- er effect on male CEOs in industries where overconfidence is more prevalent, like phar- maceuticals, computer soware, coal and construction, the researchers noted. During times of crisis, companies with female direc- tors saw their performance drop by a smaller amount than those without. "One benefit of having female directors on the board is a greater diversity of viewpoints, which is purported to improve the quality of board deliberations, especially when com- plex issues are involved, because different perspectives can increase the amount of in- formation available," the researchers wrote for HBR. "So a board with female directors might be more likely to challenge the CEO and push him to consider a wider range of options, as well as pros and cons, when mak- ing strategic firm decisions. is could then attenuate CEO overconfidence and correct for potentially biased beliefs." n Massachusetts hospital president: BCBS putting profits over patients By Morgan Haefner T he president of a Massachusetts health system and hos- pital group accused Blue Cross Blue Shield of Massa- chusetts of caring about revenues more than patients, according to an op-ed published by the Sippican Week. Keith Hovan, president of New Bedford, Mass.-based South- coast Health System and Fall River, Mass.-based Southcoast Hospitals Group, wrote in the op-ed that the health system is in the process of renegotiating its reimbursement rates with BCBSMA. Mr. Hovan said while Southcoast is commit- ted to good faith conversations with BCBSMA and hopes to sign a new contract later this year, the health system "need[s] BCBSMA to engage in meaningful negotiations that result in a timely, fair and equitable solution." Should an agreement not be reached, Southcoast's physi- cian offices, hospitals and providers will no longer be con- sidered in network for BCBSMA members beginning Jan. 1. In a Sept. 16 press release, BCBSMA addressed the nego- tiations: "Unfortunately, the Southcoast Health system has decided to terminate its contract with us unless we agree to rate increases of nearly 30 percent over four years. We value the care that Southcoast physicians and hospitals pro- vide to our members. But on behalf of our customers, we cannot agree to rate increases that will make quality health- care less affordable." n UPMC appeals vote blocking new hospital 1 mile from Allegheny Health rival By Morgan Haefner P ittsburgh-based UPMC will appeal a decision to revoke a zoning permit that would have allowed the health system to build a 63-bed hospital near a rival system, according to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. UPMC disagreed with a Sept. 16 vote from the Jeffer- son Hills Borough Zoning Hearing Board to revoke the permit. The municipality did not have a comment on the board's decision, but community members had voiced concerns about excess traffic, lighting and noise should UPMC be allowed to build the hospital. UPMC's proposed three-story hospital, to be named UPMC South Hospital, would have been located roughly a mile from Jefferson Hospital in Jefferson Hills, Pa. The hospital is operated by UPMC rival Allegheny Health Network, also based in Pittsburgh. In a statement to the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, a UPMC spokesperson said the health system looks "forward to a positive outcome as we continue to meet the growing demand for UPMC care and services." The board has 45 days to explain in writing why it voted to revoke the permit. n

Articles in this issue

view archives of Becker's Hospital Review - November 2019 Becker's Hospital Review